Wed, 08 Aug 2012 07:07:19 GMT | By Chris Aaron, Editor of Motoring & Sports
HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much?

A coach adjusts the position of a girl as she does a handstand for five minutes as part of a training session at the Gymnastics Hall of the Shanghai University of Sports August 7, 2007. Students of the gymnastics class of Yangpu District Youth Sports School are all aged 5 to 9. China's future Olympic hopefuls train at one of the thousands of provincial sports schools around the country. Even though these athletes might be too young to make the 2008 Beijing Games, they harbour dreams of winning Olympic gold in London 2012 or beyond. REUTERS/Nir Elias



HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much? (© Reuters Photo)
Next
Previous
Previous
  • HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much? (© Reuters Photo)
  • HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much? (© Reuters Photo)
  • HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much? (© Reuters Photo)
  • HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much? (© Reuters Photo)
  • HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much? (© Reuters Photo)
  • HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much? (© Reuters Photo)
  • HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much? (© Reuters Photo)
  • HYS: Is China’s Olympic training program too much? (© Reuters Photo)
Next
Reuters PhotoShow Thumbnails
Previous6 of 22Next
Share this Gallery

As of the time of writing, China leads the London 2012 Olympic medal table with 73 pieces of silverware to their name. A staggering achievement without question, but are their methods towards this commendable, or plain terrible?

Becoming an Olympic athlete - let alone a champion, is by no means an easy feat. It takes dedication, hard work, passion, motivation, and sacrifice; the stuff of, well, Olympians.

But at what cost?

*SEE GALLERY ABOVE FOR PHOTOS FROM SOME OF CHINA's GOVERNMENT-RUN PROGRAMS

Olympic medals don't come cheap; this is fact. But to pay the price of beating children into 'Olympic shape' has to be seen as some kind of ridiculousness.

China's recent run of medals and overall success at the London 2012, has yet again stirred up attention to its government-run training programs, and the sometimes brutal harshness of it.

Wu Minxia's golden horror

Media reports have recently highlighted such an issue with one Chinese diver, Wu Minxia of China - who amidst celebrating a gold medal in synchronized diving and becoming the sport's first ever three-time consecutive gold medal winner, was informed to her surprise that her grandparents had died a year earlier, and that her own mother had been battling cancer for the last eight years.

Why - you might ask, wasn't she informed of these things earlier? Her parents were quoted in a report stating that keeping the information from her was seen to be "essential" to her training.

So while the perceived "essentials" may have in fact brought her great fame and success as an all-time diving great, did it bring her happiness? Was it the right way to go about being an Olympic competitor?

China's 'Gym-nasty' program

In a more familiar instance, gymnastics in particular, is a sport that requires athletes to begin training at a very young age. And this wouldn't be the first - or the last - time that China's Olympic program for gymnasts comes to view for its often cruel regime.

In China, children at a very young age - 4 years and above - are often shipped off to intensive government-run training camps where it is purely 'survival of the fittest - and the strongest gets beaten just as much'. The best of the best are handpicked to represent the country, and the rest get to simply go home in spite of the years of "essential" training.

This is again seen in the way China celebrates its gold medal winners with loud applause and its silver-lists with no acknowledgement at all.

Having seen the videos, documentaries, pictures, it isn't all that surprising to learn of Wu Minxia's 'interrupted' medal celebrations.

At what cost would you send your children to strive for gold?

Typically, the Olympic Games are a showcase of 'amateur' athletes with a shot at global athletic glory. It is grounds where the likes of almost unheard of names to some parts of the world, such as Malaysia's Yeoh Kee Nee, can shine next to global athlete megastars such as Datuk Lee Chong Wei; on the very same platform, and all are celebrated for their achievements.

But what was done to Wu Minxia, and the many, many other athletes around the world (other countries too are known to condoneand practise these regimes) who endure similar fates can't be right. Can it? Are we to condone delight in gold medals at the cost of child abuse? Or is this what it takes to win medals?

So we put it to YOU, dear reader. What do you make of such training regimes? Are Pokemon, Ultraman and hopscotch a fair trade for abuse, pain and a gold medal?

There is much need for sacrifice in winning Olympic medals, but if you were Wu Minxia, would you be as pleased about your records and medals at the end of the day?

SIGN IN BELOW AND TELL US WHAT YOU THINK!

30Comments
Aug 9, 2012 11:24AM
avatar

Children do not have a voice...... do we feel their fear, terror, pain ? When they cling on to you, aren't they saying " Please help me , save me, I'm scared  ! "  PLEASE ...... just love them  and let them be what they are !

Aug 9, 2012 11:03AM
Aug 9, 2012 5:10PM
avatar
Ya regimental training is necessary to show off. Ya take that gold and show off.. But I prefer the person from a small island doing it by himself winning the gold. That s the joy.
Aug 9, 2012 7:59PM
avatar
It is not about the endless crazy training & punishment to blame. What makes it horrible is how they choose the path for all these kids who hasn't even explored the world and discover what their true interests are. Talk about life...
Aug 9, 2012 12:50PM
avatar

I totally agree with Don b Bossy. Be a mature reader, don't just judge from what you see or read without find out the fact.

 

A lot of irresponsible editor just manipulate those immature reader by showing photos. I'm not saying that this editor irresponsible. The key factor is to find out the fact, don't simply believe what you see but without knowing the fact.

 

MSN belongs to American. They are number 2 currently in the medal ranking to date just after CHINA. Will it be an tactic to embarrass China? We should ponder about this.

Aug 9, 2012 1:43PM
avatar
China going face the doomsday First..Full discrimination towards the people...F*** China..
Aug 9, 2012 10:53AM
avatar
inhuman act and just  for the "GOLD" not worth it.  cause life  in sport itself without family involved is just  like a machine or robots.  well, we all know China country, human's life is just like a dog, if someone badly injured on the side of the road, no body care to bring to hospital.. its so sad. feel sad for the China Olympic athlete.
Aug 9, 2012 1:48PM
avatar

understand that everyone need good disipline in order to excel. but sending children to such harch disipline seems so wrong to me..especially when they are actually living someone's else dream.

Aug 9, 2012 12:11PM
avatar

 

The debate should be if it is right for Government-sponsored full time training from childhood in order to excel in world sports? ... China & the Chinese parents(by willingly surrendering their children) seem to support these state-sponsored rigourous training of their athletes.

 

Those who has been to China recently can see how modern the society there nowadays..  I don't believe there is a  " force in it " approach for these children.

 

Other nations may adopt different approach...

 

Yes, there could be thousands who did not make it like Wu Minxia & Lin Dan; but it is just like the school systen where only the best can be picked for world competitions...

Aug 9, 2012 11:52AM
avatar
I go for the training techniques but the coaches should be more humane to their students.  Maybe the coaches should be sent to some humanitarian courses.
Aug 9, 2012 5:14PM
avatar
I share "The Little Dragon" sentiment exactly. Looking at what China has achieved is no mean feat, surely. Lots of respect and admiration for their tenacity.
Aug 9, 2012 11:35AM
avatar

Even if Wu Minxia says it is worth it, since she won the Gold Medals, but what about ****dreds

of others or even thousands (in China) in the same program, who didn't make it.  Will they take it as

they are failures and will be dicarded or do they get another chance.  Remember, there will be thousands more waiting in line to get a chance to be picked for their programs.

These 'have been' will have their childhood sacrficed for nothing and who knows what will happen to

these 'casualties'?

Aug 9, 2012 11:06AM
avatar
woooooow how they can abuse of a child for gain their gold medal?how wild are u?
Aug 9, 2012 11:12AM
avatar

Why is there a China bashing in the media these last few days ... is it pure jealousy of the gold medal counts that China has won ?

I have a feeling that these pictures are exaggerated to embarrass China.. these pictures could have been taken anywhere...  unless the athletes come forward & testify, we can't just believe these crabs.

I am proud of China's schievements...  the pictures of Wu Minxia & Lin Dan also show they are proud of winning the gold medals for both themselves & China...

Let's be fair in our judging...

Aug 9, 2012 7:45PM
avatar
Haha

I sense Sour grape here

Gold medal is for those who work the HARDEST and able to take the most EXTREME punishment. End of story.

You will not win gold medal by relaxing at home.

If we do not acknowledge this, there will never be a gold medal winner. I am sure every Olympic winner out there work hard for their gold. 

Aug 9, 2012 4:16PM
avatar
come on that's China, martial art culture still there, plus training fully sponsored by government is like whole life time investment
Aug 9, 2012 5:06PM
avatar
It's very clear from the comments that "Malaysian" Chinese are backing their "home land" China in whatever they do! They know that human has no value in China but they still argue!!! You must pray 100 times a day that you were born in Malaysian and have the Malaysian "citizenship" or else you would be one of those "hanging" there in pain!!!
Aug 9, 2012 4:19PM
avatar
Different cultures have different ways to do things and this is no exception. I doubt the westerns go thru easier training. For some reason due to white supremacy or whatever other reasons there may be, westerners like pointing out at Asia. Just let us be and celebrate Asian victory.
Aug 10, 2012 1:03AM
avatar
More often people are interested in the result but the key things in life are the process which brings about the result. What is the point of celebrating a moment of happiness but having to go through a process full of emotional torture and unhappiness.
Report
Please help us to maintain a healthy and vibrant community by reporting any illegal or inappropriate behavior. If you believe a message violates theCode of Conductplease use this form to notify the moderators. They will investigate your report and take appropriate action. If necessary, they report all illegal activity to the proper authorities.
Categories
100 character limit
Are you sure you want to delete this comment?

Latest Sports Features

Olympic headlines